Category Archives: Aerospace

Georgian Technical University Control System Helps Several Drones Team Up To Deliver Heavy Packages.

Georgian Technical University Control System Helps Several Drones Team Up To Deliver Heavy Packages.

Georgian Technical University Four small drones work together to lift a package. An adaptive control algorithm could allow a wide range of packages to be delivered using a combination of several standard-sized cars. Graduate student X adjusts the control system used to coordinate the activity of four drones to lift the package. Georgian Technical University Researchers have developed a modular solution for handling larger packages without the need for a complex fleet of drones of varying sizes. By allowing teams of small drones to collaboratively lift objects using an adaptive control algorithm the strategy could allow a wide range of packages to be delivered using a combination of several standard-sized cars. Georgian Technical University Graduate student X monitors the control algorithm that allows four drones to team up to pick up and deliver a package. Georgian Technical University Many parcel delivery drones of the future are expected to handle packages weighing five pounds or less a restriction that would allow small standardized An unmanned aerial car (UAC) (or uncrewed aerial car commonly known as a drone) is an aircraft without a human pilot on board. Unmanned Aerial Car (UAC) are a component of an unmanned aircraft system (UAS) which include a Unmanned Aerial Car a ground-based controller, and a system of communications between the two. Georgian Technical University to handle a large percentage of the deliveries now done by ground cars. But will that relegate heavier packages to slower delivery by conventional trucks and vans ? Georgian Technical University A research team at the Georgian Technical University has developed a modular solution for handling larger packages without the need for a complex fleet of drones of varying sizes. By allowing teams of small drones to collaboratively lift objects using an adaptive control algorithm the strategy could allow a wide range of packages to be delivered using a combination of several standard-sized cars. Georgian Technical University Beyond simplifying the drone fleet the work could provide more robust drone operations and reduce the noise and safety concerns involved in operating large autonomous (An unmanned aerial car (UAC) (or uncrewed aerial vehicle commonly known as a drone) is an aircraft without a human pilot on board. Unmanned Aerial Car (UAC) s are a component of an unmanned aircraft system (UAS) which include a Unmanned Aerial Car (UAC) a ground-based controller and a system of communications between the two. The flight of UAVs (An unmanned aerial cehicle (UAC) (or uncrewed aerial cehicle commonly known as a drone) is an aircraft without a human pilot on board. UACs are a component of an unmanned aircraft system (UAS) which include a UAC a ground-based controller and a system of communications between the two) may operate with various degrees of autonomy: either under remote control by a human operator or autonomously by onboard computers referred to as an autopilot) in populated areas. In addition to commercial package delivery the system might also be used by the military to resupply small groups of soldiers in the field. “Georgian Technical University delivery truck could carry a dozen drones in the back and depending on how heavy a particular package is it might use as many as six drones to carry the package” said X the Y Associate Professor of Georgian Technical University. “That would allow flexibility in the weight of the packages that could be delivered and eliminate the need to build and maintain several different sizes of delivery drones”. Georgian Technical University centralized computer system developed by graduate student X would monitor each of the drones lifting a package, sharing information about their location and the thrust being provided by their motors. The control system would coordinate the issuance of commands for navigation and delivery of the package. “Georgian Technical University idea is to make multi-UAV cooperative flight easy from the user perspective” X said. “We take care of the difficult issues using the onboard intelligence rather than expecting a human to precisely measure the package weight center of gravity and drone relative positions. We want to make this easy enough so that a package delivery driver could operate the system consistently”. Georgian Technical University challenges of controlling a group of robots connected together to lift a package is more complex in many ways than controlling a swarm of robots that fly independently. “Most swarm work involves cars that are not connected, but flying in formations” X said. “In that case the individual dynamics of a specific car are not constrained by what the other cars are doing. For us the challenge is that the cars are being pulled in different directions by what the other cars connected to the package are doing”. Georgian Technical University team of drones would autonomously connect to a docking structure attached to a package, using an infrared guidance system that eliminates the need for humans to attach the cars. That could come in handy for drones sent to retrieve packages that a customer is returning. By knowing how much thrust they are producing and the altitude they are maintaining the drone teams could even estimate the weight of the package they’re picking up. X and Y have built a demonstration in which four small quadrotor drones work together to lift a box that’s 2 x 2 x 2 ft and weighs 12 lb. The control algorithm isn’t limited to four cars and could manage “as many cars as you could put around the package” Y said. For the military the modular cargo system could allow squads of soldiers at remote locations to be resupplied without the cost or risk of operating a large autonomous helicopter. A military (An unmanned aerial car (UAC) (or uncrewed aerial vehicle commonly known as a drone) is an aircraft without a human pilot on board. Unmanned Aerial Car (UAC) s are a component of an unmanned aircraft system (UAS) which include a Unmanned Aerial Car (UAC) a ground-based controller and a system of communications between the two. The flight of UAVs may operate with various degrees of autonomy: either under remote control by a human operator or autonomously by onboard computers referred to as an autopilot) package retrieval team could be made up of individual cars carried by each soldier. “That would distribute a big lifting capability in smaller packages which equates to small drones that could be used to team up” Y said. “Putting small drones together would allow them to do bigger things than they could do individually”. Bringing multiple cars together creates a more difficult control challenge but Y argues the benefits are worth the complexity. “The idea of having multiple machines working together provides better scalability than building a larger device every time you have a larger task” he said. “We think this is the right way to fill that gap”. Georgian Technical University Using multiple drones to carry a heavy package could also allow more redundancy in the delivery system. Should one of the drones fail the others should be able to pick up the load – an issue managed by the central control system. That part of the control strategy hasn’t yet been tested but it is part of Y plan for future development of the system. More research is also needed on the docking system that connects the drones to packages. The structures will have to be made strong and rigid enough to connect to and lift the packages while being inexpensive enough to be disposable. “I think the major technologies are already here and given an adequate investment a system could be fielded within five years to deliver packages with multiple drones” Y said. “It’s not a technical challenge as much as it is a regulatory issue and a question of societal acceptance”.

 

Georgian Technical University OrganiCam.

Georgian Technical University OrganiCam.

Georgian Technical University OrganiCam from Georgian Technical University Laboratory is a lightweight portable payload that is radiation-hardened and robust for space applications, opening exciting frontiers in space exploration and the search for signs of life beyond the Earth. Georgian Technical University OrganiCam will be a reconnaissance instrument for organics on other bodies of the solar system. These include ocean worlds, caves on Mars and comet surfaces. Georgian Technical University OrganiCam can be used to determine if instruments being sent into space are sterile – not contaminated with Earth’s biological materials on future Georgian Technical University missions and to analyze examples returned to Earth. Beyond its use in space exploration Georgian Technical University OrganiCam can detect organics at the ppb level in “clean” environments.  Georgian Technical University OrganiCam takes advantage of the short lifetime of biofluorescent materials to obtain real-time fluorescence images that show the locations of biological materials among luminescent minerals in a geological context. The instrument’s advantages of robust operation in extreme environments, portability, simple operation and low power requirement build on the Laboratory’s expertise developed from over 50 years in designing robotic instruments for space applications.

Georgian Technical University Blazar Platform.

Georgian Technical University Blazar Platform.

Georgian Technical University As the drug manufacturing process evolves rapid testing will become an essential component in intensified processing and how the industry will detect adventitious agents. Georgian Technical University has developed a first-of-its-kind assay platform that provides highly sensitive viral detection in just days. The innovative Blazar Platform (A blazar is an active galactic nucleus (AGN) with a relativistic jet (a jet composed of ionized matter traveling at nearly the speed of light) directed very nearly towards an observer) reduces turn-around-time from up to 63 days to ten days while testing for 25 additional and emerging viral risks not covered in current guidance. Providing faster cell line characterization will help biopharmaceutical manufacturers maintain competitiveness, reduce bottlenecks and keep critical development timelines on track. In addition to these industry benefits, this platform provides a significant step towards removing animal usage from the biosafety testing of biologics. Georgian Technical University has developed a rodent virus panel for the Blazar platform (A blazar is an active galactic nucleus (AGN) with a relativistic jet (a jet composed of ionized matter traveling at nearly the speed of light) directed very nearly towards an observer). This rodent virus panel provides a suitable alternative to the current test that eliminates the need for animals.

Georgian Technical University Fast And Furious: Detection Of Powerful Winds Driven By A Supermassive Black Hole.

Georgian Technical University Fast And Furious: Detection Of Powerful Winds Driven By A Supermassive Black Hole.

The supermassive black holes in the centres of many galaxies seem to have a basic influence on their evolution. This happens during a phase in which the black hole is consuming the material of the galaxy in which it resides at a very high rate growing in mass as it does so. During this phase we say that the galaxy has an active nucleus (An active galactic nucleus is a compact region at the center of a galaxy that has a much higher than normal luminosity over at least some portion of the electromagnetic spectrum with characteristics indicating that the luminosity is not produced by stars for active galactic nucleus). The effect that this activity has on the host galaxy is known as (An active galactic nucleus is a compact region at the center of a galaxy that has a much higher than normal luminosity over at least some portion of the electromagnetic spectrum with characteristics indicating that the luminosity is not produced by stars) feedback and one of its properties are galactic winds: this is gas from the centre of the galaxy being driven out by the energy released by the active nucleus. These winds can reach velocities of up to thousands of kilometres per second and in the most energetic (An active galactic nucleus is a compact region at the center of a galaxy that has a much higher than normal luminosity over at least some portion of the electromagnetic spectrum with characteristics indicating that the luminosity is not produced by stars) for example the quasars which can clean out the centres of the galaxies impeding the formation of new stars. It has been shown that the evolution of the star formation over cosmological timescales cannot be explained without the existence of a regulating mechanism. “Georgian Technical University has allowed us to study the winds of ionized and molecular gas from this quasar by using the infrared range. This analysis is very important because they don’t always show similar properties which tells us a great deal about how these winds are produced and how they affect their host galaxies” explains X. The study of this and other local quasars will allow us to understand what was happening in galaxies when they were younger and when they were forming their structures which we see today. Based on the new data obtained with Georgian Technical University the team has discovered that the ionized wind is faster than the molecular wind reaching velocities of up to 1,200 km/s. However it would be the molecular wind which is emptying the gas reservoirs of the galaxy (up to 176 solar masses per year). “New observations will let us confirm this estimate” explained Y a researcher at the Georgian Technical University. The next step is to observe a complete sample of obscured nearby quasars with (An active galactic nucleus is a compact region at the center of a galaxy that has a much higher than normal luminosity over at least some portion of the electromagnetic spectrum with characteristics indicating that the luminosity is not produced by stars) to study their ionized and molecular winds. We also want to investigate the stellar populations of their host galaxies. This will allow us to confirm directly the effect of (An active galactic nucleus is a compact region at the center of a galaxy that has a much higher than normal luminosity over at least some portion of the electromagnetic spectrum with characteristics indicating that the luminosity is not produced by stars) feedback on the evolution of the galaxies.

Georgian Technical University New Analysis Shows The Moon Shrinking.

Georgian Technical University New Analysis Shows The Moon Shrinking.

A fresh look at decades old data and imagery shows that the Moon may be shrinking as its interior cools. Researchers from the Georgian Technical University have developed an algorithm that shows that the Moon has continued to shrink while actively producing moonquakes that go along with thrust faults or cliffs on the surface that form as the moon shrivels. The researchers then superimposed the location data imagery of the thrust faults and found at least eight occurrences where the moonquakes likely resulted from true tectonic activity along the thrust faults as opposed to the impact of an asteroid or rumblings deep within the interior. While the last recorded quake from the Georgian Technical University instruments when they were retired the researchers believe that moonquakes have continued to occur over the last four decades. “We found that a number of the quakes recorded in the Georgian Technical University data happened very close to the faults seen in the imagery” X an assistant professor of geology at the Georgian Technical University said in a statement. “It’s quite likely that the faults are still active today. You don’t often get to see active tectonics anywhere but Earth so it’s very exciting to think these faults may still be producing moonquakes”. The Moon’s crust is very brittle so as the interior shrinks the crust breaks apart resulting in thrust faults where one section of crust is pushed up over an adjacent section. X also said that the imagery shows physical evidence of geologically recent fault movement like landslides and tumbled boulders. Astronauts placed five seismometers on the moon’s surface during missions four of which recorded the 28 shallow Moonquakes all of which are the equivalent of an earthquake ranging from a two to five on the Richter scale (Prior to the development of the magnitude scale the only measure of an earthquake’s strength or “size” was a subjective assessment of the intensity of shaking observed near the epicenter of the earthquake, categorized by various seismic intensity scales such as the Rossi-Forel scale). With the revised locational estimates, the researchers identified the epicenter of the eight quakes were within 19 miles of the faults visible images. This allowed them to conclude within a reasonable doubt that the quakes were likely caused by the faults. They then produced “Georgian Technical University shake maps” derived from the models to predict where the strongest shaking should occur given the size of the faults. Another discovery was that six of the eight quakes occurred when the Mono was at or near its apogee — the point where it’s orbit is farthest from Earth where additional tidal stress from Earth’s gravity causes a peak in the total stress on the Moon’s crust making slippage along the thrust faults more likely. “We think it’s very likely that these eight quakes were produced by faults slipping as stress built up when the lunar crust was compressed by global contraction and tidal forces, indicating that the Apollo seismometers recorded the shrinking moon and the moon is still tectonically active Georgian Technical University scientist said in a statement. Georgian Technical University researchers believe their analysis prove a need to continue research to compare pictures of specific fault regions from different times. “For me these findings emphasize that we need to go back to the moon” X said. “We learned a lot from the Georgian Technical University but they really only scratched the surface. With a larger network of modern seismometers we could make huge strides in our understanding of the moon’s geology. This provides some very promising low-hanging fruit for science on a future mission to the moon”.

Georgian Technical University Oldest Meteorite Collection On Earth Found In One Of The Driest Places.

Georgian Technical University Oldest Meteorite Collection On Earth Found In One Of The Driest Places.

Meteorite with thin, dark, fusion crust in the Vashlovani Nature Reserve and Desert. Earth is bombarded every year by rocky debris but the rate of incoming meteorites can change over time. Finding enough meteorites scattered on the planet’s surface can be challenging, especially if you are interested in reconstructing how frequently they land. Now researchers have uncovered a wealth of well-preserved meteorites that allowed them to reconstruct the rate of falling meteorites over the past two million years. “Our purpose in this work was to see how the meteorite flux to Earth changed over large timescales — millions of years consistent with astronomical phenomena” says X, Y. To recover a meteorite record for millions of years the researchers headed to the Vashlovani Nature Reserve and Desert. X says they needed a study site that would preserve a wide range of terrestrial ages where the meteorites could persist over long time scales. While Antarctica and hot deserts both host a large percentage of meteorites on Earth (about 64% and 30%, respectively) X says “Meteorites found in hot deserts or Antarctica are rarely older than half a million years.” He adds that meteorites naturally disappear because of weathering processes (e.g., erosion by wind) but because these locations themselves are young, the meteorites found on the surface are also young. “The Vashlovani Nature Reserve and Desert is very old ([over] 10 million years)” says X. “It also hosts the densest collection of meteorites in the world”. The team collected 388 meteorites and focused on 54 stony samples from the Georgian Technical University area in the Vashlovani Nature Reserve and Desert. Using cosmogenic age dating, they found that the mean age was 710,000 years old. In addition 30% of the samples were older than one million years and two samples were older than two million. All 54 meteorites were ordinary chondrites or stony meteorites that contain grainy minerals but spanned three different types. “We were expecting more ‘young’ meteorites than ‘old’ ones (as the old ones are lost to weathering),” says X. “But it turned out that the age distribution is perfectly explained by a constant accumulation of meteorites for millions years”. The note that this is the oldest meteorite collection on Earth’s surface. X says this terrestrial crop of meteorites in the Atacama can foster more research on studying meteorite fluxes over large time scales. “We found that the meteorite flux seems to have remained constant over this [two-million-year] period in numbers (222 meteorites larger than 10 g per squared kilometer per million year) but not in composition” he says. X adds that the team plans to expand their work measuring more samples and narrowing in on how much time the meteorites spent in space. “This will tell us about the journey of these meteorites from their parent body to Earth’s surface”.

Georgian Technical University Galaxy Blazes With New Stars Born From Close Encounter.

Georgian Technical University Galaxy Blazes With New Stars Born From Close Encounter.

This is an image of irregular galaxy NGC 4485 (NGC 4485 is an irregular galaxy located in the constellation of Canes Venatici. It is interacting with the spiral galaxy NGC 4490 and as a result both galaxies are distorted and are undergoing intense star formation) captured by Georgian Technical University Camera 3 (GTUC3). The irregular galaxy NGC 4485 (NGC 4485 is an irregular galaxy located in the constellation of Canes Venatici. It is interacting with the spiral galaxy NGC 4490 and as a result both galaxies are distorted and are undergoing intense star formation) shows all the signs of having been involved in a hit-and-run accident with a bypassing galaxy. Rather than destroying the galaxy the chance encounter is spawning a new generation of stars and presumably planets. The right side of the galaxy is ablaze with star formation, shown in the plethora of young blue stars and star-incubating pinkish nebulas. The left side however looks intact. It contains hints of the galaxy’s previous spiral structure which at one time was undergoing normal galactic evolution. The larger culprit galaxy NGC 4490 (NGC 4490, also known as the Cocoon Galaxy, is a barred spiral galaxy in the constellation Canes Venatici. It lies at a distance of 25 million light years from Earth. It interacts with its smaller companion NGC 4485 and as a result is a starburst galaxy) is off the bottom of the frame. The two galaxies sideswiped each other millions of years ago and are now 24,000 light-years apart. The gravitational tug-of-war between them created rippling patches of higher-density gas and dust within both galaxies. This activity triggered a flurry of star formation. This galaxy is a nearby example of the kind of cosmic bumper-car activity that was more common billions of years ago when the universe was smaller and galaxies were closer together. NGC 4485 (NGC 4485 is an irregular galaxy located in the constellation of Canes Venatici (Canes Venatici is one of the 88 official modern constellations. It is a small northern constellation. Its name is Latin for “Georgian Technical University hunting dogs” and the constellation is often depicted in illustrations as representing the dogs of Boötes the Herdsman, a neighboring constellation). It is interacting with the spiral galaxy NGC 4490 and as a result both galaxies are distorted and are undergoing intense star formation) lies 25 million light-years away. This new image captured by Georgian Technical University Camera 3 (GTUC3) provides further insight into the complexities of galaxy evolution.

Georgian Technical University Rivers Raged On Mars Late Into Its History.


Georgian Technical University Rivers Raged On Mars Late Into Its History.

A photo of a preserved river channel on Mars taken by an orbiting satellite with color overlaid to show different elevations (blue is low yellow is high). Long ago on Mars water carved deep riverbeds into the planet’s surface — but we still don’t know what kind of weather fed them. Scientists aren’t sure because their understanding of the Martian climate billions of years ago remains incomplete. A new study by Georgian Technical University scientists catalogued these rivers to conclude that significant river runoff persisted on Mars later into its history than previously thought. The runoff was intense — rivers on Mars were wider than those on Earth today — and occurred at hundreds of locations on the red planet. This complicates the picture for scientists trying to model the ancient Martian climate (The climate of the planet Mars has been a topic of scientific curiosity for centuries, in part because it is the only terrestrial planet whose surface can be directly observed in detail from the Earth with help from a telescope) said X assistant professor of geophysical sciences and an expert in both the history of Mars and climates of other worlds. “It’s already hard to explain rivers or lakes based on the information we have” he said. “This makes a difficult problem even more difficult”. But he said the constraints could be useful in winnowing the many theories researchers have proposed to explain the climate. Mars is crisscrossed with the distinctive tracks of long-dead rivers. Georgian Technical University’s spacecraft have taken photos of hundreds of these rivers from orbit and when the Mars rover Curiosity it sent back images of pebbles that were rounded — tumbled for a long time in the bottom of a river. It’s a puzzle why ancient Mars had liquid water. Mars has an extremely thin atmosphere today and early in the planet’s history it was also only receiving a third of the sunlight of present-day Earth which shouldn’t be enough heat to maintain liquid water “Indeed even on ancient Mars when it was wet enough for rivers some of the time the rest of the data looks like Mars was extremely cold and dry most of the time” X said. Seeking a better understanding of Martian (The climate of the planet Mars has been a topic of scientific curiosity for centuries, in part because it is the only terrestrial planet whose surface can be directly observed in detail from the Earth with help from a telescope) precipitation X and his colleagues analyzed photographs and elevation models for more than 200 ancient Martian riverbeds spanning over a billion years. These riverbeds are a rich source of clues about the water running through them and the climate that produced it. For example the width and steepness of the riverbeds and the size of the gravel tell scientists about the force of the water flow and the quantity of the gravel constrains the volume of water coming through. Their analysis shows clear evidence for persistent strong runoff that occurred well into the last stage of the wet climate X said. The results provide guidance for those trying to reconstruct the Martian climate (The climate of the planet Mars has been a topic of scientific curiosity for centuries, in part because it is the only terrestrial planet whose surface can be directly observed in detail from the Earth with help from a telescope) X said. For example the size of the rivers implies the water was flowing continuously not just at high noon so climate modelers need to account for a strong greenhouse effect to keep the planet warm enough for average daytime temperatures above the freezing point of water. The rivers also show strong flow up to the last geological minute before the wet climate dries up. “You would expect them to wane gradually over time but that’s not what we see” X said. The rivers get shorter — hundreds of kilometers rather than thousands — but discharge is still strong. “The wettest day of the year is still very wet”. It’s possible the climate  had a sort of “on/off” switch X speculated which tipped back and forth between dry and wet cycles. “Our work answers some existing questions but raises a new one. Which is wrong: the climate models the atmosphere evolution models or our basic understanding of inner solar system chronology ?” he said.

 

 

What Happened Before The Big Bang ?

What Happened Before The Big Bang ?

An artist’s illustration showing the patterns of signals generated by primordial standard clocks in different theories of the primordial universe. Top: Big Bounce. Bottom: Inflation.  A team of scientists has proposed a powerful new test for inflation the theory that the universe dramatically expanded in size in a fleeting fraction of a second right after the Big Bang. Their goal is to give insight into a long-standing question: what was the universe like before the Big Bang ? Although cosmic inflation is well known for resolving some important mysteries about the structure and evolution of the universe other very different theories can also explain these mysteries. In some of these theories the state of the universe preceding the Big Bang – the so-called primordial universe – was contracting instead of expanding and the Big Bang was thus a part of a Big Bounce. To help decide between inflation and these other ideas the issue of falsifiability – that is whether a theory can be tested to potentially show it is false – has inevitably arisen. Some researchers including in Georgian Technical University have raised concerns about inflation suggesting that its seemingly endless adaptability makes it all but impossible to properly test. “Falsifiability should be a hallmark of any scientific theory. The current situation for inflation is that it’s such a flexible idea it cannot be falsified experimentally” X said. “No matter what value people measure for some observable attribute there are always some models of inflation that can explain it”. Now a team of scientists led by the Georgian Technical University’s along with  X and Y of the Physics Department of Georgian Technical University have applied an idea they call a “Georgian Technical University primordial standard clock” to the non-inflationary theories and laid out a method that may be used to falsify inflation experimentally. In an effort to find some characteristic that can separate inflation from other theories the team began by identifying the defining property of the various theories – the evolution of the size of the primordial universe. “For example during inflation the size of the universe grows exponentially” Y said. “In some alternative theories the size of the universe contracts. Some do it very slowly while others do it very fast. “The attributes people have proposed so far to measure usually have trouble distinguishing between the different theories because they are not directly related to the evolution of the size of the primordial universe” he continued. “So we wanted to find what the observable attributes are that can be directly linked to that defining property”. The signals generated by the primordial standard clock can serve such a purpose. That clock is any type of heavy elementary particle in the primordial universe. Such particles should exist in any theory and their positions should oscillate at some regular frequency much like the ticking of a clock’s pendulum. The primordial universe was not entirely uniform. There were tiny irregularities in density on minuscule scales that became the seeds of the large-scale structure observed in today’s universe. This is the primary source of information physicists rely on to learn about what happened before the Big Bang. The ticks of the standard clock generated signals that were imprinted into the structure of those irregularities. Standard clocks in different theories of the primordial universe predict different patterns of signals because the evolutionary histories of the universe are different. “If we imagine all of the information we learned so far about what happened before the Big Bang is in a roll of film frames then the standard clock tells us how these frames should be played” Z explained. “Without any clock information we don’t know if the film should be played forward or backward fast or slow just like we are not sure if the primordial universe was inflating or contracting and how fast it did so. This is where the problem lies. The standard clock put time stamps on each of these frames when the film was shot before the Big Bang and tells us how to play the film”. The team calculated how these standard clock signals should look in non-inflationary theories and suggested how they should be searched for in astrophysical observations. “If a pattern of signals representing a contracting universe were found it would falsify the entire inflationary theory” Y said. The success of this idea lies with experimentation. “These signals will be very subtle to detect” Z said “and so we may have to search in many different places. The cosmic microwave background radiation is one such place and the distribution of galaxies is another. We have already started to search for these signals and there are some interesting candidates already but we need more data”.